Welcome to Heavenly Creamery
Heavenly Creamery, nestled in a charming former church in Conneaut, OH, is a beloved local ice cream haven. Known for its rich, handcrafted ice cream, the creamery delights visitors with an array of flavors, from classic favorites to unique creations. Patrons rave about the warm, welcoming atmosphere, complete with church pew seating that invites relaxation and enjoyment. The friendly owners strive to customize experiences, ensuring each visit is memorable. With offerings like refreshing bubble teas and creamy milkshakes, it’s no wonder customers travel from afar to enjoy what many describe as the best ice cream around. Join the community and savor a scoop of happiness at Heavenly Creamery!
-
264 Sandusky St, Conneaut, OH 44030 Hotline: (440) 593-6080
Welcome to Heavenly Creamery, a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Conneaut, Ohio. Located at 264 Sandusky St, this charming ice cream shop offers a uniquely warm and inviting atmosphere that stems from its roots as a former church. The classic wooden pews provide not just seating but an experience filled with nostalgia and comfort, making it a perfect spot for families and ice cream lovers alike.
At Heavenly Creamery, the ice cream is truly heavenly. Each batch is crafted on-site with rich and decadent ingredients that turn any visit into a flavorful adventure. Their menu boasts an impressive array of options — from the classic Choc Dip Cone priced at just $1.60 to indulgent desserts like the Banana Split at $10.00. The Soft Serve Milkshake is a must-try, available for only $4.50, offering a delightful texture and an array of flavors.
- Ice Creams:
- Choc Dip Cone - $1.60
- Small Cone - $4.00
- Banana Split - $10.00
- Novelties:
- Ice Cream Cookie - $1.25
- Cannoli - $3.50
- Beverages:
- Bubble Tea - $4.50
- Frozen Lemonade - $2.75
- Can Pop - $1.25
Beyond the delicious ice cream, what truly sets Heavenly Creamery apart is its commitment to customer service and community. As noted by many patrons, the friendly staff creates an inviting atmosphere, making every visit feel personal. Testimonials from happy customers like Lauren R. rave about seasonal favorites such as ginger molasses ice cream paired with warm pumpkin spice cookies. It's evident that this little shop is beloved by locals and tourists alike.
The reviews speak volumes. Whether you’re on a family outing or simply seeking a sweet treat, many have traveled hours just to relish the ice cream offerings at Heavenly Creamery. Gary H. shared, “Drove an hour to get there and definitely worth the drive,” a sentiment echoed by many who have discovered the rich, diverse flavors that change regularly.
Furthermore, Heavenly Creamery embraces all ice cream enthusiasts, including those seeking dairy-free options. With a variety of non-dairy sorbets, everyone can indulge in a cold treat on a hot day.
In conclusion, Heavenly Creamery is more than just an ice cream shop; it’s a community hub where memories are made over scoops of deliciousness. From exceptional service to a cozy, unique setting, every visit is a reminder of the joy that good food, and good company can bring. So, whether you’re a Conneaut local or just passing through, don’t miss the chance to experience the bliss of Heavenly Creamery. Indulge in the flavors of happiness today!
Great rich ice cream made on site. You won't find better. The only thing I miss about living in Conneuat is the ice cream.
Great ice cream and various flavors really like the Sundaes! The location is awesome! Services is awesome to the owners are very friendly and willing to make whatever you like
Best ice cream with different flavors all the time. Love the atmosphere with the church pews
Yummy good ice cream with excellent service. Drove an hour to get there and definitely worth the drive.
Great ice cream . Many different flavors to choose from and great service . I highly recommend this place for anyone who loves ice cream n
Absolutely love this place!!! Every fall I've gotten their ginger molasses ice cream and have it with warm pumpkin spice cookies from the oven. Their ice cream is literally the best. And trust me, I've gone on tours at ice cream factories all over the country. This is honestly the best and it's right in my backyard!
Best ever, even Zola loves it! You would be a fool to not go out of your way to come here.
Heavenly Creamery is a locally owned place to get ice cream. It has lots of basic and interesting flavors. Many are the usual classics but there's some more interesting ones. Good service and prices aren't bad. They also have a non dairy sorbet. Cool places for sitting inside. It was an old church before becoming an ice cream place. The old pews are the seats. It has a fairly big menu for not having that much space inside. There's a mix of classic and modern flavors for a decent price. It has some healthier choices.They have a grape sorbet. It's about $3.50 for a cup. They give you a lot. It also has a loyalty card. Save by bringing it in. They give you a free bowl when it's completed so don't forget you have this.
Heavenly Creamery is an ice cream shop in a church. I'm always pleased to see former church buildings being reutilized. And I'm always happy to see ice cream shops. Heavenly Creamery had good selection and lots and lots of seating and standing room. You could bring a whole team of kids here after a game and everyone would not only fit but be able to walk around.. It's too bad that I don't recall what I had at Heavenly Creamery, but it was four months ago! I know I liked it. I'll be sure to go by the next time I am in Conneaut.