Heavenly Creamery Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to Heavenly Creamery, where ice cream dreams come true! Nestled at 264 Sandusky St in Conneaut, OH, this charming bakery promises an indulgent experience for all dessert lovers.

The menu features a delightful array of treats, including soft serve milkshakes at $4.50 and rich, homemade ice creams served in whimsical cones or pre-filled quarts. For a refreshing twist, try their frozen lemonade or sweet tea with boba, starting at just $2.75. The fusion of classic flavors like Texas sheet cake and seasonal delights like ginger molasses ice cream guarantees satisfaction for every palate.

The unique setting, a repurposed church complete with pew seating, adds a touch of nostalgia while enjoying these delectable desserts. With rave reviews emphasizing both the quality and service, Heavenly Creamery is not just a dessert shop; it's a beloved community gem that beckons ice cream enthusiasts from near and far!